Beauty or Beast?

I forgot to post about this earlier, but I went to Target and saw that Rafe made an affordable line of bags. I had seen how designers (Isaac, Behnaz, Paul & Joe) did clothing lines for The Store That Is My World, but I was surprised to see bags...big bags.
I stood there for awhile holding this bag, not sure if I liked it or not. I liked that it was only $50 and said "rafe new york" on it (shallow, I know), but is it really good looking? I was actually looking at the blue one, checking the insides to see if it could double as a diaper bag (a reviewer on target.com planned to use it as one). I still don't know! It's rather shiny, but if it does look good...then that's a pretty damn good deal. I wish it came in white. I would've been sold. This little one below is cute but doesn't work with my lifestyle.
Maybe this black one would be suitable. Is it too shiny? I'm not so sure if I like shiny...but I'm kind of liking the bag as a whole...

Bless you, Target. May every designer out there come to you over the years.